Tim Withers

How to Think Outside the SEO Keyword Research Box

by Tim Withers

2011/07/29

 

SearchImage Credit: Joe Graci

The more things change, the more they stay the same. While SEO tactics have evolved and diversified virtually year on year since the advent of the industry in the mid-90s, keyword research is still arguably the most important piece of any successful SEO project.

If your site doesn’t adequately target relevant phrases, it doesn’t matter how well structured it is, or how many backlinks it has. Basically, if your keyword strategy isn’t up to snuff, your SEO efforts are pretty much dead in the water.

An effective keyword strategy targets a selection of short and long-tail keywords chosen with user behaviour in mind. Often the most difficult part of this process is placing yourself in the users’ shoes and considering their journey from beginning to end.

Brand immersion will only take you so far, and the more resources you have to reference, the better. It’s easy to get lazy and simply use the same tools or techniques over and over again. While this might save you time in the short term, it will likely limit your results further down the line; at which point you’ll need to waste valuable hours revisiting and revising your strategy.

As such, I’m always on the hunt for new sources of inspiration. Every job I do, I start out with some initial market research and then seek out potential consumer touch points. Fighting the urge to just take keywords and plug them into a tool has forced me think outside the box and as a result I’ve uncovered some fantastic resources that have provided invaluable insight. Below are a few examples:

Amazon

Amazon provides customers with the facility to tag products with applicable keywords. Where films and books are concerned, these keywords often stretch beyond generic terms, and touch on subject matter and themes.

Obviously this technique can’t be used for all clients, but in the instances where it does lend itself to a specific product or service, it can be very powerful.

Q&A sites

Q&A sites are a great source of long-tail content. The likes of Yahoo! Answers allow you to browse by category, and as such you can quickly hone in on long-tail search phrases that could be relevant to your keyword and content strategy.

Social Media bookmarking sites

Bookmarking sites, such as Delicious and Amplify, cover an array of topics and themes. Within these categories, you’ll find literally millions of articles that users have submitted – each with relevant tags.

Like Amazon, referencing these sites won’t provide value in all cases, but taking note of the words users associate with various types of content can provide valuable insight.

Knowem.com is a good starting point as it provides a list of bookmarking sites, which you can find here.

Custom search strings

Recently I’ve been playing around with custom search strings for keyword research. One particularly useful string I’ve leveraged is: "powered by wordpress" inurl:tags intitle:your keyword.

This will get Google to return the tags pages of WordPress blogs that match your keyword. Similarly, "most used thread tags" intitle:keyword and "tags for this thread" intitle:keyword  will help you unearth forum threads related to your niche and see what keywords users have tagged them with.

The above strings only work for vBulletin forums, but can be modified to help you harvest data from forums running on other software (e.g. Invision Power Board and phpBB), provided these platforms have similar functionality.

Wordtracker keyword questions

Enter a short-tail keyword – for example, ‘car hire’ – into Wordtracker’s Keyword Questions tool and it spits out related questions consumers are asking (based on Wordtracker’s keyword data).

This is an amazing source of both short and long-tail keyword ideas, and the tool has recently evolved to include modifiers that make it even more potent.

Adwords search query reports

This requires that you have access to pre-existing Adwords data, and as such often isn’t feasible. If you do have some campaigns set up though, I highly recommend you take a few hours to analyse the results.

In addition to providing further insight into keyword search volume, search query reports may help you uncover keyword ideas you wouldn’t have thought of otherwise; particularly those of the long-tail variety.

Leveraging search trends & upcoming events

Finally, here’s something a little different. This isn’t so much a keyword research technique as a content strategy built around search trends. I like to call it the pre-emptive keyword research strike (PKRS).

As you know, it’s much easier rank for a search phrase when you get the jump on your competitors. By keeping an eye on emerging trends, and being mindful of any upcoming events relevant to your niche, you can craft content and build links to it months before the SERPs become saturated with similar sites, pages or blog posts.

 

Also check out:

 

About The Author

Comments

GREAT post Tim. Search strings are resources I haven't been using yet. Any opinions on using questions as post titles? I watched a webenar the other day where Gina Gaudia-Graves went into some depth as to why she uses this.

Posted by peter on 2011/07/30

Hey Peter

Thanks, glad you enjoyed it. :)

I think questions make for great page titles, because a) they can be used to target long-tail search phrases incredibly effectively, and b) having a question as a page title helps differentiate your result from others in the SERPs, which can result in increased CTRs.

With that said, I don't believe in writing question-style page titles just for the sake of it, as this can result in clunky page titles that aren't as well optimised for keywords as the more common keyword | keyword approach. If a question lends itself to your page title and targeted keywords, that's great, but I think it's important to practice moderation.

Posted by Tim Withers on 2011/08/01

I still believe that the best way to go foward is to list a few quick keywords that are very specific or related to the page you want to optimize, and then analyze them in the google keyword tool. A lot of those suggestions/alternatives given from there are good to go with relatively good search volumes.

Your resources listed above are good to start off from, but won't use them as my final or main resource for keyword resource.

BUT, thanx for listing these!

Posted by Wiehan Britz on 2011/08/01

Hi Wiehan, thanks for your comment.

I've found myself using the keyword tool less and less, especially for territories outside North America, as the volumes displayed for many keywords just aren't accurate.

With that said, the tactics above aren't intended as substitutes for a keyword tool; they're more alternative points of reference that might help spark ideas.

Q&A sites, Wordtracker's keyword questions, search query reports and Google Suggest aren't especially powerful where long-tail optimisation is concerned.

Posted by Tim Withers on 2011/08/01

Good feedback!

I do get your point on the accuracy of the Google tool, but what other tool gives you search volume or data so you can manage to pinpoint the top performing keywords?

Would you mind to communicate just in a few steps exactly how you guys go ahead with keyword research, coz so there are so much confusion and 'sitting in the dark' when it comes to keyword research?

Have a sweet day

Posted by Wiehan Britz on 2011/08/02

I think that's where brand immersion is so important. There honestly isn't any keyword tool that doesn't need to be taken with a bucketful of salt.

We all have our own way of doing things, but when receiving a brief everyone does as much background research as they can. Obviously the extent of this research is dependent on how much time is allowed, but it's usually fairly exhaustive.

The result is a long list of terms and phrases that we then whittle down by referencing a combination of keyword tools, Google Suggest, Analytics (if it's an existing site), Webmaster tools (likewise), and any feedback or insight the client can provide (which often proves invaluable).

So, probably not all that different from how everyone else approaches the process, although we definitely spend longer than average familiarising ourselves with the intrinsics before getting our hands dirty.

Posted by Tim Withers on 2011/08/02

Great string! How much value would you attach to competitors (High SERP) keywords? Not only the Meta KW's, but what the actual site density words are?

Posted by peter on 2011/08/02

Yeah, it's good to get some debate going in here. :)

I cast an eye over competitors' content but I don't place too much stock in their choice of keywords, to be honest. I prefer to look at what they're doing as a whole and then consider how we can one-up them.

Although it's always interesting to take a look at a successful site to see what makes Google tick.

Posted by Tim Withers on 2011/08/02

I agree with your post. Limiting yourself in doing keyword research isn't bad, but keep in mind that it will only show limited results. So, why not try to go beyond and expand your area of expertise to gather more resources? Good job on your post Tim!

Posted by real estate seo on 2011/08/17

This post is good, whenever I just visit blogs I comes across some shitty articles written for search engines and irritate users but this information is quite good. It is simple, good and straightforward.

Posted by iodine supplement on 2011/10/04

Hi Tim Withers,

Thank you for this excellent post.

Keyword should not be the one and only important criteria to gain high rank.Google has currently introduced the "freshness factor". So content of the website should be updated regularly to give the essence of freshness.

Thanks again
Regards

Posted by Arpita on 2012/05/22

Make a comment

To prevent GottaQuirk from becoming spam central, we block the use of certain words like porn, sex etc. We apologise for any inconvenience, but can't spend our lives deleting messages left by spammy friends.

Captcha