In Google we trust?
by Werner deBruin
Last week I looked at who the top 10 SA sites with the most authority are, and investigated why Google favours them more than others.
Well, I decided that there is more to it than just the number of backlinks and pages indexed. So I did what we do best at Quirk, and played cricket...I mean did a little more digging.
But first, I need to explain some of the inconsistencies with the results from the tool in our previous report. Why did we get some negative values in the results for IOL and SA Gov sites? This was what it looked like:
|
IOL
|
South African Government
|
||||||||||||
|
|
So what’s up with the inconsistent results?
Well, if you look at www.gov.za; when we do an index search on Google, you’ll make use of the “site:gov.za” command – then it comes up with the usual 221,000 pages indexed on Google.
So when you do use the correct command to check for supplemental results (site:gov.za *** -view), then Google gives out bogus information like 997,000 pages.
So for the final act, I checked site:gov.za –view ; that showed 1,110,000 results. A big difference don’t you think? Unfortunately Google blocked me, so I could not supply the same results for IOL, but figures don’t add up.
But gov.za is also a top level national domain. Does Google perhaps treat TLND's differently? Could the figures have changed so drastically in a week? Or should the real question be, how much do we trust the results supplied be Google…
Comments
post a commentSmith, do you mean "What results does Yahoo show?" or do you mean "What about the top 10 sites on Yahoo?"
Posted by Werner on 2007/05/17
Well, Yahoo shows a total of 826,569 pages in its index. No results for supplemental unfortunately, as its a Google specific term. But from a trust point of view - in my opinion - I feel that Yahoo's results (especially backlinks) are more reliable in general.
Posted by Werner on 2007/05/18
Subscribe
RSS to Email
Get our latest blog posts delivered straight to your inbox.
eMarketing News
Subscribe to our fortnightly newsletter which is packed with interesting eMarketing news, views and other quirky titbits.
September
| S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
| 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 |
| 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 |
| 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 |
| 28 | 29 | 30 | ||||
Archives
Categories
- General (543)
- PPC & Affiliates (27)
- Search Engine Marketing (83)
- WebPR (37)
- Online Reputation Management (33)
- Email Marketing (9)
- Design (15)
- Viral Marketing (167)
- Conversion Optimisation (13)
- Website Development (32)
- Industry Events (58)
- Quirky Stuff (90)
- Social Media (82)
- Work at Quirk (3)
- Friday Fact Box (12)
- Interviews (7)
- Guest Posts (2)
Recent Posts
- The Most Influential People Online
- Most Wanted Wiener
- The Bear Trap
- Friday Fact Box - Podcasts
- Guest Post - eHealth Revolutionising Health Systems
Recent Comments
- Claire on The Bear Trap
- reenasally on Orangina: Animals Behaving Badly
- SuperSanti on Hello The World
- Sarah Manners on Orangina: Animals Behaving Badly
- Kat on Orangina: Animals Behaving Badly
More photos of the QuirkStars At Play
Name:
Friends of Quirk
Websites:
www.quirk.biz
Why not address the question to Mr Matt Cutts at Google ?
He might surprise you and give an explanation.
Posted by Sergei Muller on 2007/05/16