Bring Me the WikiScanner!

by Carlos Menezes

The power that Wikipedia has on our lives is really something. For many it's the first port of call for any information on a topic. Some (myself included) often search for a topic on the public encyclopaedia before even Googling it (inevitably, Googling a subject almost always brings its Wikipedia entry as one of the first two SERP results).

I have lost count of the times at varsity that the core of our last minute research would, to our lecturers’ disdain, be drawn from the online encyclopaedia’s entries. And I can’t even hazard a guess as to how many hours I spend every week hopping from one random subject to another. It’s gotten so bad that this addiction is mutating, and as a Star Wars fan I now find myself hopelessly trapped in the clutches of Wookieepedia.

Don’t laugh…

Unfortunately, as with so many offerings, Wikipedia’s main strength is also its greatest hindrance. The fact that users can edit entries has detracted greatly from its credibility as a reputable source, and there have been reports of many corporations and politicians altering their own entries to portray themselves in as favourable a light as possible.

With Wikipedia being such a powerful hub of information almost any large scale Online Reputation Management campaign would start with “tidying up” the relevant entries. This has created a massive amount of scepticism among academics and the public at large, and perhaps as a result of this we have seen the spawning of some parodies, with Uncyclopedia and Encyclopedia Dramatica being two of the best known.

For an example of the disdain with which some folk hold Wikipedia take a look at the former’s entry on our topic of discussion.

(For an absolute laugh take a look at the entry on aardvarks.)

Now a tool has been developed that’s set to provide some insight into the objectivity of Wikipedia editors. WikiScanner has the capacity to trace the source of changes to the world’s most popular encyclopaedia, and has already uncovered some interesting findings:

The New York Times Company has changed the entries of George W. Bush and Condoleeza Rice, adding the word “jerk” 12 times to the former’s page and replacing “pianist” with “penis” on the latter’s.
The CIA added “Wahhhhhh!” before Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s stated plans for his presidency.
The US Democratic Party labelled Rush Limbaugh, the right-wing talk show host, a “racist”, a “bigot” and “idiotic”.

WikiScanner can’t tell you the individual that made the changes, only that they originated from a specific network. So, for now, it’s safe to assume that it was in fact a NY Times employee that displayed leftist tendencies or that a black-suited, grim faced CIA operative suddenly developed a sense of humour.

I reckon it’s quite a cool advancement, but it’ll only be a matter of time until ORM experiences escalation. Now that we can track who made the changes to the most popular source of information on the Internet, how long will it be till organisations start framing each other?

2007/08/22 | permalink | comments (3) | trackbacks (0)

Comments

Rss to Email

Get our latest blog posts delivered straight to your inbox.

eMarketing News

Subscribe to our fortnightly newsletter which is packed with interesting eMarketing news, views and other quirky titbits.

July

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17	18	19
20	21	22	23	24	25	26
27	28	29	30	31

« Jun

Aug »

Recent Comments

Australian Mortgage broker on Peer-to-peer lending or social loan sharks?

Mortgage broker Brisbane: FREE SERVICE. Find out how much MC Mortgages can drop your interest rate. - Mortgage broker Brisbane.
Anthony on The Democratic Alliance's Online Plan

Thanks for the article Kat, and you were spot-on in response to Shaun: my resources comment was not so much about being able to afford an online presence (most political parties in SA - all the ones you've heard of - have one); it was more about the fact that you need to have the human resources to sustain what you initiate. As an example, we started SA Today in response to ANC Today, and we've sustained it week in and week out (as has the ANC, even if its President has decided not to continue where his predecessor left off). Both the ID and the IFP have started similar initiatives, but they find it difficult to sustain, so it ends up being occasional, rather than weekly.
In response to Nic, providing strong principled opposition and defence of the constitution is a key part of the DA's brand, and one of the key things our supporters and potential supporters want from us. But the second important thing potential DA voters want (most important for many) is for us to offer solutions to the country's problems. We do that through a comprehensive policy platform which is effectively a manifesto of what we undertake to do if elected to government. That doesn't mean we don't recognise the enormity of the challenge ahead of us.
Kat on Can You Put the eMarketing Textbook in the Hands of Someone Who Needs It?

@Hilary, you can actually already order a hard copy directly from the website, just follow this link www.quirk.biz/emarketingtextbook/buy
we'll definitely let you know when it's in book shops as well though :)
@mike Less tree killing is always a good idea. The cd idea is intriguing, and would probably be great for people who have limited connectivity but are keen to learn.
Hilary Cross on Can You Put the eMarketing Textbook in the Hands of Someone Who Needs It?

Hi Kat, please let us know when the hard copy is out, I'd definatley like to purchase one for myself.
Thanks,
Hilary
Mike Metelerkamp on Can You Put the eMarketing Textbook in the Hands of Someone Who Needs It?

Kat, this is proving to be quite a mind bender...
How about creating those mini cd's and trying to get them inserted into some marketing/business/IT text books - or give them to universities to hand out in lectures?
Really cheap and less tree killing :)
Mike

More photos of the QuirkStars At Play

Name:
Friends of Quirk
Websites:
www.quirk.biz

Skribit: Social Suggestions

Name:
E-mail:
Url:
Comments:
Markup guide: makes text bold // makes text italic // -- creates a link -- (two dashes, no http://)
Remember personal info?
Notify me of follow-up comments?
SPAMCHECK:

Bring Me the WikiScanner!

by Carlos Menezes

Comments

Subscribe

Rss to Email

eMarketing News

July

Archives

Categories

Recent Posts

Recent Comments